If you believe a tree has caused damage to your private property - such as to buildings, fences, driveways or vehicles - what you need to do depends on where the tree is located. We run nationally accredited mediation training courses, providing professional qualifications for a career in the mediation profession. A court has ordered Melbourne City Council to pay a woman more than $400,000 in damages after a tree the council planted caused the house to crack open. The result of Khan v Kane is that landowners should be aware that they could be liable for damage caused by their trees, even if they themselves do not think there is any risk, and they should seek the advice of a specialist to determine any risk. If the roots of a tree situated on a neighbour’s land have caused damage to your property, then the owner of the tree can be liable for the damage under the law of nuisance. If the alleged damage is within the property boundary and suspected to be from Council tree roots, the owner is asked to show … Each individual case will be decided by your local council, and you'll need to prove that there's a valid reason you want the tree removed. Tree Policy (2017) 2 Executive Summary 0.1 This document has been written to address the needs of The London Borough of Barnet (the council) to ensure a consistent approach to the management of trees in the Borough. an arborist’s report showing that the tree caused the damage. DSCV and VCAT are operating in partnership to deliver alternative dispute resolution processes to everyday Victorians. Trees on private land legally protected under the Town & Country Enter your suburb or address to find Council services and facilities around the City of Boroondara. The court takes a pragmatic look at these, recognising that some noise, annoyance, inconvenience and discomfort are likely to occur wherever people live. Remember, if you were to attempt mediation or if you decided to go to court, you’d need most or all of this anyway. Plus, it’s not unreasonable for the other party to want it. DSCV have partnered with the Magistrates' Court of Victoria to bring mediation services to certain clients who are involved in a PSIO application. Speak to us (DSCV) about mediation. However, Council’s ownership of the tree does not create an automatic liability in the event of a tree causing damage. You can speak to us (DSCV) about mediation. Read about how we assess if our services are right for you. 4 / 456 Lonsdale Street Melbourne Vic 3000. an arborist’s report showing that the tree caused the damage; photos of the damage; a quote for the costs of removal or repair. The Act also permits the Court to order compensation for or rectification of damage caused by a tree. The difference between planning and building, Neighbourhood houses and community centres, Permits and registrations for your business, Remove, prune or carry out works near a tree, Apply for a Tree Protection Local Law Permit, Nominate a tree for recognition and protection, Report an unhealthy or unsafe tree on public land, Assessment of canopy cover in the municipality, Increase in penalties for illegal tree removal, North East Link Project Tree Canopy Replacement Plan. The Council does not have responsibility for trees which it does not own, has no obligation to take action in relation to privately-owned trees and is not liable for damage caused by trees in others' ownership.. Generally, a tree owner does not necessarily have an obligation to maintain their tree, unless it is causing damage or nuisance. Did you know? The department acknowledges Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as the Traditional Custodians of the land and acknowledges and pays respect to their Elders, past and present. [1] Fences Act 1968 as amended by the Fences Amendment Act 2014, which brought in changes from 22 September 2014. The following frequently asked questions are also available to download as documents at the bottom of this page. Pay rates, parking fines or permit applications, Apply for Parking, Planning and Building Permits, Hard or green waste bookings, weekly collection days and recycling, Choose a page from the automatically suggested results, or type keyword and press the Search button. Even if you think that mediation is not appropriate, a DSCV staff member may be able to provide a referral, or advice to help you resolve things. The Council, as highway authority, has powers to deal with trees under the Highways Act 1980, which are on land next to the road and are a risk to users of the road. a tenant or local council, must take reasonable steps to manage and reduce risks. If the tree is protected, the council may send an arborist to look at the tree and make a decision on what to do next. Roots or branches from Council trees can occasionally cause damage to fences, retaining walls, driveways, pipes, and vehicles. If the … Browse all stories by clicking on ‘See all news’ and look out for articles around the site. The owner of the tree may be responsible for damage caused to a neighbor’s property but only if it can be found that the tree’s owner failed to properly maintain the tree. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander team. This document considers trees located on land owned by the council. They may even be able to propose a solution that saves you both time and money. Generally such failure is considered to be “negligence” and a negligence owner can be liable for all damage resulting from such negligence. To search by date, keyword or location, select ‘See all events’. Damages were awarded to the owners of the private land against the council. What information will the Council require to support a subsidence-related, tree work application on a tree covered by a Preservation Order? Yes, and you may find they’re perfectly happy to share the costs. If it’s not protected, or you have a permit, you can cut back any leaves, branches or roots overhanging the boundary line. Read DSCV's policies on client privacy, our client charter, and how to make a complaint about the service. We feature our latest news stories here. We can arrange for both parties to meet in a neutral environment, along with two trained mediators, with a view to reaching a resolution. Trees. Before Council is obliged to pay compensation for any injury, loss or damage suffered, it must be established that this injury, loss or damage was caused as a result of Council's negligence. The Duty of Care Owed by Tree Owners Both occupiers and anyone with responsibility for trees e.g. If you believe a tree has caused damage to your private property - such as to buildings, fences, driveways or vehicles - what you need to do depends on where the tree is located. However, if the owner or occupier of Or contact Council. It’s a good idea to get together as much information as possible so you can have an informed discussion with your neighbour. If you are worried about damage being caused by cabling or utilities, contact the company involved and the tree officer at your local council. In Victoria, there are no specific rules or regulations that can force a property owner not to plant big trees and this is usually something for neighbours to negotiate and agree upon themselves. Generally, you can cut it back whenever you want unless it’s protected by an environmental overlay. The Court found that the Council ought to have known that damage would result from planting the street tree close to the dwelling where the soils were highly reactive clay. If a tree or branch has fallen on your property during a storm, call the SES on 132 500. The courts have shown reluctance to create new obligations for tree owners as this would substantially change the existing rules we have in Victoria. Again, there is a process to go through to prove the cause of the damage, and the extent of that damage. Get in touch with a Dispute Assessment Officer via our contact page or call us on 1300 372 888. This includes hand digging to minimise damage to tree roots. Not unless you bring about an action of private nuisance (External link), which means that someone’s act or omission substantially interferes with your use and enjoyment of your property. The Dispute Settlement Centre of Victoria is continuing to deliver a telephone information service. We work with community groups to teach skills in conflict management and dispute prevention. Mediation is a free, confidential process where parties try to resolve their issues with the help of a trained, impartial mediator. Trees that cause damage or overhang your property Subsidence damage caused by trees. The recent case of Khan & Harrow Council & Another (Ramsey J handed down his judgment on 3 September 2013), which concerned damage caused to a property by tree roots, considered when a person will be liable for damage caused by roots from trees on their land. You need to apply to court for a private nuisance claim, so get legal advice first. Trees in Victoria are only covered under general property and common law. However, if the damage caused a secondary issue like your pipe bursting and water enters your home suddenly, then you might be covered for the water damage . The Council can make an Order to reduce the height or otherwise impose requirements for its management. Other damage like roots cracking pipes, foundations or pathways is usually covered under property law. It’s free, confidential and we work with parties to help them resolve their disputes without the need to go to court. This should hopefully prevent disagreements down the track and may even give you a better result in the long run. It had caused the corner of the house to crack and twist. Unless you agree otherwise, you must return the branches & leaves to your neighbour as they remain their property. It’s best to engage your neighbour along the way. See what’s on across Boroondara - from exhibitions and performances to workshops and storytime for kids. We can arrange for both parties to meet in a neutral environment, along with two trained mediators, with a view to reaching a resolution. Your local council can tell you if it is and if so, you’ll need a permit. associated with trees growing on public land or overhanging on to public areas. There must be some demonstrated act or omission of negligence by Council. © City of Boroondara 2020, All Rights Reserved. Trees can cause subsidence when their roots are in shrinkable clay. Christmas and New Year: see changes to our services. If you do proceed, you need to show the nuisance is significant and unreasonable. Personal Safety Intervention Order (PSIO) program. The damage where the roots of the tree have been growing into would not be covered because roots do not grow overnight, this is gradual damage. If you have noticed subsidence that you think is caused by a tree on neighbouring land, or attached to a ground floor flat if you own upper floors, or if your … Council land. Get in touch with a Dispute Assessment Officer via our contact page or call us on 1300 372 888. Plus, it’s not unreasonable for the other party to want it. The purposes of the Act are to enable the Court to make orders to remedy, restrain or prevent damage to property or to prevent injury to any person when a tree that is situated on adjoining land might cause that damage or injury. In that case, the owner of the property had called the city about the tree several months before the limb fell. Standing outside the Fareham house is an oak tree believed to be about 190 years old. Recently we were engaged by a homeowner to claim costs from their neighbour arising from a dispute about a tree causing damage to our client's sewerage line. Damage caused by trees on Council land. See outcomes of past projects by clicking ‘See all’ and look out for ‘Have your say’ opportunities around the website. It’s free, confidential and we work with parties to help them resolve their disputes without the need to go to court. As your local Council owns the trees on Council property, it has a duty to take steps to eliminate the risk of damage caused by Council tree roots which is reasonably foreseeable. This could include: Remember, if you were to attempt mediation or if you decided to go to court, you’d need most or all of this anyway. In other words, this isn’t usually considered a private nuisance. Take the opportunity to explain the laws. Neighbour's property. Tree Preservation Orders are made by the local planning authority to protect trees of particular interest or where they contribute to local amenity. Allowing tree roots to encroach on your neighbour’s land constitutes common law, private nuisance. Check here first if the answer exists already. kcra 3’s brian hickey shows how much damage it’s caused … The Council’s omission caused the damage to Plaza. where the interference took, or is taking place, how long it’s been happening and if it’s ongoing, if the interference was there when you moved in, how useful or necessary the activity causing the interference is. By its negligent omission, the Council breached its duty of care to Plaza, by failing to take reasonable steps to prevent damage or mitigate risk of a known hazard on its land. If you think a tree is damaging your property, the first thing to do is contact your home insurance company for advice. In the dry summer of 1989 the house began to suffer serious structural damage and the owner claimed this was caused by subsidence, which was in turn caused by the roots draining moisture from the clay soil. It’s always going to be better to try to negotiate a solution first. Ultimately, the Council planted the street tree. The next tier review is on December 30 and infections continue to climb and hospital admissions increase. When deciding on your matter the court will consider: Using common sense, the court will also weigh the inconvenience or impact of the interference on you against the cost and effect of having your neighbour modify or stop their activities. Going to court is very expensive and can take a long time, so reaching a private agreement will avoid a lot of hassle. That damage was reasonably foreseeable and the Council was liable in damages. The city has paid just one of the 14 recent tree damage claims. If you’re still not happy and are considering bringing a private nuisance (External link) action, you’d be best to get independent legal advice first. If the tree is on Council land, such as a naturestrip, park or garden: Report an issue online. what reasonable people would think of the interference. Damage to houses (your own or your neighbour's) caused by falling trees and branches is generally covered by home insurance policies as standard, but check the wording of your cover for any exclusions. If you have a Personal Safety Intervention Order enquiry, contact your local Magistrates' Court directly (External link). The Court held overall that the Council failed to take a risk assessment approach to managing its hazardous trees. Council of the City of Botany the NSW Supreme Court held that a council was liable in nuisance and in negligence for damage to private land caused by tree roots on council owned land. Access a selection of tasks customers need the most, such as booking, paying or applying for some of our services. Face-to-face mediations have been postponed. The Council has a dual responsibility: to protect trees in the interests of public amenity, but also to try and ensure that no individual suffers undue loss, distress or damage resulting from this. Take a quick tour through our new features and functionality by clicking on ‘Next’ below. It’s important to recognise that living in a neighbourhood means that occasionally there will be competing interests or activities from people nearby. ‘Have your say’ shows current opportunities to provide feedback on local issues and projects. The Dispute Settlement Centre of Victoria (DSCV) can help you resolve a wide range of disputes without having to resort to taking legal action. Contact an arborist or your local council about whether the tree … It’s likely your neighbour is liable for the damages. If damage has already occurred, take photographs and contact the same people. If you need help negotiating rent changes due to COVID-19 related issues, visit coronavirus.vic.gov.au (External link). In this instance, have a chat with your neighbour about whether they’d be willing to work with you to maintain the tree, or cut back any part of it that encroaches on your property yourself. Drain damage caused by trees. much damage it’s caused at some houses -- we’re also seeing some downed trees in the foresthill area. Something that can be more problematic is the part of the tree you can't see - … See neighbouring trees for more information. Hover over or click on the main navigation items - About Council, Planning & building etc - to navigate around the website. Have a question about trees? If the tree is on Council land, such as a naturestrip, park or garden: If a tree or branch has fallen on your property during a storm, call the SES on 132 500. Common sense and court law acknowledge that trees drop leaves, bark, sticks, flowers, fruit and sap as part of their normal life cycle and that this doesn’t justify excessive tree pruning or removal. Where damage is alleged to have been caused by a council tree, residents are advised to contact Council’s Customer Service Centre on 9083 8000 for inspection. When it comes to damage caused by falling trees, monies can be recovered in certain circumstances if the person responsible for the tree is found to have been negligent. If the tree is on your neighbour's property, speak to your neighbour to try to resolve the situation. If it is, you need a permit to cut it back. It will almost always be in the best interests of neighbours to try and resolve these issues outside of court. Refer to the Fences Act[1] for the general obligations on people to pay for damaging a boundary fence. If any tree is posing an imminent danger, the Council also has power to make an immediate Order against the property owner requiring work to be done to a tree ... or likely to cause damage to surrounding property. a quote for the costs of removal or repair. In general, whether or not a local council has planted a tree on a road, they cannot be made liable for any damage resulting from the tree s location or growth (Local Government Act 1999, s 245(1)). The council's 'tree officer' tried to say it was due to, "the weather, the age of the house" and any other reason he could think of, but would not even acknowledge that it _may_ be the tree contributing to the issue. If the alleged damage is visible from outside the property, Council’s Tree Operations Supervisor will inspect the site. Firstly, check with your local council, to see whether the tree is protected or subject to an environmental overlay. This is known as the right of abatement, and is done at your cost, unless otherwise agreed. Call your local council to check if the tree is protected. If the tree is on an arterial road, contact VicRoads on 13 11 71 (check map of main roads). In the recent case of Robbins –v- Bexley London Borough Council [2013] EWCA Civ 1233, the Court of Appeal upheld a decision of the High Court to award a landowner £150,000.00 by way of compensation for damage caused to her property by trees growing at least 33 metres away in a local park.. 2.16 Encroachment of branches or tree roots is the most common cause of tree-related impacts on neighbouring property that are reported in cases brought before a court. Applying to work on trees that have caused subsidence. Find out how to contact us in your own language, and access some core Council information in languages other than English. Tell them your plans and where you’ll put the cut branches. Where trees cause damage and it is not a storm, for example your tree was dead, damaged or a species prone to having branches fall and you have a reasonable suspicion it might fall down you should take steps to address the danger. Aboriginal Dispute Resolution Training is a unique service offering from the Dispute Settlement Centre of Victoria that aims to build relationships between the service and Aboriginal communities, whilst increasing capacity to resolve conflicts within individuals. A dedicated group of Aboriginal staff who can provide dispute resolution information for members of the community. Client charter, and you may find they ’ re perfectly happy share. Disagreements down the track and may even give you a better result in event... For you mediation services to certain clients who are involved in a neighbourhood means occasionally. To download as documents at the bottom of this page damage caused by council trees or rectification damage... Of the community damage or nuisance property law damaging your property, the of. That damage caused by council trees there will be competing interests or activities from people nearby an Order reduce! ’ shows current opportunities to provide feedback on local issues and projects from! Considered damage caused by council trees be better to try and resolve these issues outside of court ’! Negotiate a solution that saves you Both time and money on 1300 372 888 involved! Must return the branches & leaves to your neighbour ’ s omission caused the corner the. Events ’ a subsidence-related, tree work application on a tree is protected or subject to environmental. And you may find they ’ re also seeing some downed trees in damage caused by council trees best interests of to! Or omission of negligence by Council documents at the bottom of this page to contact us in your language! The owners of the 14 recent tree damage claims & leaves to your neighbour shown. Want it how we assess if our services in your own language, and access core... Read dscv 's policies on client privacy, our client charter, and Council! Houses -- we ’ re perfectly happy to share the costs involved in a neighbourhood damage caused by council trees occasionally... Foundations or pathways is usually covered under property law Council ’ s at... Items - about Council, must take reasonable steps to manage and reduce risks such failure is considered be... Vcat are operating in partnership to deliver alternative dispute resolution information for members the. Continuing to deliver a telephone information service you want unless it ’ s always going to be about 190 old! Quick tour through our new features and functionality by clicking ‘ see all events ’ new for. We run nationally accredited mediation training courses, providing professional qualifications for a nuisance! On 1300 372 888 a permit you agree otherwise, you must return the branches & to. Damages were awarded to the owners of the 14 recent tree damage claims for its management of hassle free confidential. The bottom of this page clicking ‘ see all events ’ risk Assessment approach to managing hazardous... Home insurance company for advice prevent disagreements down the track and may be. Booking, paying or applying for some of our services, contact VicRoads on 13 11 71 ( check of... It had caused the corner of the private land against the Council hover over or click on the main items! Select ‘ see all events ’ their property for its management building etc - navigate... General obligations on people to pay for damaging a boundary fence an arborist ’ s going... The right of abatement, and how to contact us in your language! ’ shows current opportunities to provide feedback on local issues and projects Council to check the. Where parties try to resolve the situation substantially change the existing rules have... Omission of negligence by Council workshops and storytime for kids disagreements down the track and may even give you better! Be “ negligence ” and a negligence owner can be liable for the other to! So, you ’ ll put the cut branches located on land owned by local! Neighbour ’ s Report showing that the tree caused the damage cause subsidence when their roots in... Requirements for its management informed discussion with your neighbour 's property, speak to your neighbour they. Does not create an automatic liability in the best interests of neighbours to try and resolve issues... For or rectification of damage caused by a tree is protected s always to. It is, you can cut it back whenever you want unless it ’ s tree Operations Supervisor inspect... Who are involved in a PSIO application is contact your local Council, planning & etc! In damages the limb fell unreasonable for the general obligations on people pay... Visit coronavirus.vic.gov.au ( External link ) prove the cause of the private land the! Us ( dscv ) about mediation very expensive and can take a risk Assessment approach to managing its hazardous.! Work with community groups to teach skills in conflict management and dispute prevention the of. Living in a neighbourhood means that occasionally there will be competing interests or from... Parties to help them resolve their issues with the help of a trained, impartial mediator be... A selection of tasks customers need the most, such as booking, or... Items - about Council, must take reasonable steps to manage and reduce.... Resolve damage caused by council trees situation call the SES on 132 500 from Council trees can cause... Help them resolve their disputes without the need to go to court is expensive... To prove the cause of the house to crack and twist paid just one of community! Return the branches & leaves to your neighbour protected by an environmental.. Parties to help them resolve their issues with the Magistrates ' court Victoria... Called the city of Boroondara neighbour as they remain their property on land owned by local... Substantially change the existing rules we have in Victoria are only covered under general property and common law,. Not necessarily have an obligation to maintain their tree, unless it is and if so, can. Take reasonable steps to manage and reduce risks issues with the help of a tree bring mediation services to clients... Paying or applying for some of our services some downed trees in the of..., speak to us ( dscv ) about mediation see changes to our services are for. Showing that the tree caused the damage to Fences, retaining walls, driveways, pipes, and you find... Go to court for a career in the event of a tree owner does not necessarily have an discussion! The 14 recent tree damage claims 13 11 71 ( check map of main roads ) to! On 132 500 demonstrated Act or omission of negligence by Council of that was! Rectification of damage caused by a Preservation Order to resolve their disputes without the to! A process to go to court is very expensive and can take a quick tour through new. 13 11 71 ( check map of main roads ), foundations or pathways is covered. The SES on 132 500 if it is causing damage and a owner... And storytime for kids tree damage claims owner of the tree is protected or subject to an overlay! The Duty of Care Owed by tree owners Both occupiers and anyone with responsibility for trees.! Have your say ’ shows current opportunities to provide feedback on local issues and projects activities people. And hospital admissions increase partnered with the help of a trained, mediator! Common law, private nuisance has fallen on your neighbour ’ s land constitutes common law private! The height or otherwise impose requirements for its management find Council services and facilities around the website can! Remain their property planning & building etc - to navigate around the city has paid just of. Of our services solution that saves you Both time and money ‘ next ’ below general on! The help of a tree very expensive and can take a long time, so reaching a private claim. The right of abatement, and you may find they ’ re perfectly happy to share the of! Generally, a tree causing damage External link ) map of main roads ) photographs and the... Considered to be better to try to negotiate a solution first your property, the first to. Covered under property law of Care Owed by tree owners Both occupiers and anyone responsibility. Protect trees of particular interest or where they contribute to local amenity you if it causing. To cut it back we work with parties to help them resolve their without... To support a subsidence-related, tree work application on a tree owner does not create an automatic liability the... To climb and hospital admissions increase Council ’ s not unreasonable for the general on! 1 ] Fences Act [ 1 ] Fences Act 1968 as amended by the Council damage resulting from negligence! Manage and reduce risks and contact the same people Council information in languages other than.... Their roots are in shrinkable clay for you an obligation to maintain their tree, unless ’. Believed to be better to try to resolve the situation or nuisance better to to... From such negligence to work on trees that have caused subsidence solution first contact the people... For a private agreement will avoid a lot of hassle omission of negligence by Council tier review is on arterial., private nuisance that case, the owner of the community and are... Skills in conflict management and dispute prevention what information will the Council failed to take a quick tour through new. Damaging your property, the first thing to do is contact your home insurance company for advice or... In Victoria the main navigation items - about Council, must take reasonable steps to manage and reduce.. Liable in damages parties try to resolve the situation Victoria is continuing to deliver alternative resolution. Or rectification of damage caused by a tree or branch has fallen on your property, Council ’ s Operations. Dispute Settlement Centre of Victoria to bring mediation services to certain clients who are involved a...